Woman Dies After Being Impaled by Reusable Metal Straw

metal straws

While reusable metal straws are being promoted as being safer for the environment than their plastic counterparts, a new story out of England shows they may not be safe for humans. Elena Struthers-Gardner was holding a glass that contained a 10-inch-long stainless-steel straw. She fell while walking due to a medical condition, and the straw impaled her eye. Struthers-Gardner suffered fatal brain injuries as a result.

The news has sparked concern over the trendy new straws, with many wondering whether they are safe to use.

Who Is Liable for Reusable Metal Straw Accidents?

Whether or not the manufacturer is responsible for accidents involving reusable straws depends on three elements. These are the design of the straw, potential defects, or if the manufacturer knew of a danger and failed to warn consumers.

Starbucks recalled reusable straws the coffee company sold in 2016 due to a design defect. The company’s straws had a textured bottom. This was to prevent the straws from coming loose from a Starbucks cup. However, that same textured bottom lacerated and cut the inside of people’s mouths, mostly children. This is a design flaw in the straw, and Starbucks could be held liable if serious injuries result, regardless of the fact that the straws have been recalled.

It’s currently unclear if there was a design flaw or defect in the straw used by the woman in England. If there was, the manufacturer could be held liable. Now, though, with stories like this emerging, manufacturers may have to begin including warning labels on their straws if they don’t already.

It’s not only manufacturers that can be held liable for dangerous straws, or any other defective product. Anyone involved in the storing or handling of the product, such as a retailer, can also be liable if they mishandled the product. For example, if a retailer or supplier bent the box, causing damage to the straws, and a consumer was cut by a broken straw, the injured individual could also file a claim against these parties.

What to Do If You’ve Been Hurt by a Dangerous Product

Most people don’t expect to be hurt by the products they use. As such, they may not know what to do when this happens. If a dangerous product causes an injury, you need to take the following steps:

  • Get medical treatment for your injuries as soon as possible.
  • Do not throw the product away if it is safe to keep it.
  • If you must discard the product, take pictures of it, particularly of the defect.
  • Gather any documentation pertaining to the purchase or maintenance of the product.

The product, pictures of the product, and other documentation will all help support your claim if you pursue a lawsuit against the manufacturer, supplier, or retailer. A Chicago product liability attorney can help you with your claim, and it is important to speak to one as soon as possible.

Talk to a Product Liability Attorney for Free Now

If you’ve been injured in an accident due to a dangerous or defective product, contact our Chicago product liability attorneys at Salvi, Schostok & Pritchard, P.C. You could be entitled to compensation to help pay for the cost of your injuries, and we can help you pursue it. Contact us online for your free consultation.

Eirene N. Salvi joined Salvi, Schostok & Pritchard P.C. in 2016 and was named Partner in 2025. She concentrates her legal practice on cases involving medical malpractice, personal injury, and product liability. In her time with the firm, she has recovered more than $575 million on behalf of her clients. Ms. Salvi is a well-respected member of the legal community and involved in number of legal associations, including the ADR Task Force for the Illinois Judicial Conference, Illinois Supreme Court’s Judicial Selection Committee, Illinois Supreme Court’s Commission on Professionalism, Young Professionals Board of the Chicago Bar Foundation, and an officer of the board of JABA Educational Foundation.

Education: Bachelor’s degree in European History, cum laude, Pacific Union College, law degree from the University of Notre Dame Law School

Awards:

  • Law Bulletin Media “40 Illinois Attorneys to Watch Under Forty”
  • National Association of Women Lawyers “Rising List”
  • Law Bulletin Media “Top Women Lawyers Chicago Metro Area”
  • Asian American Bar Association of Greater Chicago “Rising Star Award”
  • The Jury Verdict Reporter and Law Bulletin Media “Trial Lawyer Excellence Award”
  • Best Lawyers “Ones to Watch”
  • Super Lawyers “Rising Stars”
  • Law Bulletin Media “Emerging Lawyers”
  • Illinois State Bar Association “Diversity Leadership Award”

Memberships: Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Bar Association, Illinois Trial Lawyers Association, American Association for Justice, and National Asian Pacific American Bar Association

Bar Admissions:

  • Illinois Bar
  • U.S. District Court, Northern District of Illinois General Bar
  • U.S. District Court, Central District of Illinois
  • U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Wisconsin
  • U.S. District Court, Northern District of Illinois Trial Bar

Connect with me on LinkedIn
View my Avvo profile